Myrtle, Whitby - September 2026 Real Estate Report

Myrtle, Whitby Real Estate Update: Solid Prices, But the Market Is Telling Us Something

The Vibe Right Now

If you own a house in Myrtle, you are sitting on serious value. The average HonestDoor Price for houses here is $1,586,870 - up 5.27% from the previous period. That is not a small number. But here is the honest part: the predicted market value for houses is currently sitting at $1,507,402, and that figure is slipping below the 3-month moving average of $1,532,154. Values have dipped 2.85% recently. So yes, we have strong underlying prices, but the short-term trend is worth watching. This market is not crashing - it is taking a breather.

There are no condo numbers in the mix for Myrtle right now, so we are talking houses exclusively. And houses here are firmly in the premium tier for this part of Whitby.

• Average HonestDoor Price: $1,586,870
• Predicted Market Value: $1,507,402
• 3-Month Moving Average: $1,532,154
• Recent Price Change: -2.85%
• Average Rental Estimate: $5,738 per month
• Rental Yield: 4.08%
• Airbnb Estimate: $285 per night
• Airbnb Rank in Whitby: 6th
• Growth Rank: 7 out of 11 neighbourhoods in Whitby

The Secret Sauce - Why Your HonestDoor Price Matters More Than Your Tax Assessment

Here is the thing most Myrtle homeowners do not realize. Your city assessment is a snapshot from the past. It does not move when the market moves. The HonestDoor Price is updated in real time, pulling in actual sales data and current market signals. Right now, that gap between your assessed value and your HonestDoor Price could be significant - and it matters whether you are refinancing, selling, or just trying to understand what your biggest asset is actually worth today.

With a HonestDoor Price of $1,586,870, Myrtle houses are priced well above the predicted market value of $1,507,402. That spread is your real-world check. Do not wait for the next assessment cycle to find out where you stand.

The Neighbourhood Leaderboard

On the growth leaderboard, Myrtle ranks 7th out of 11 comparable neighbourhoods in Whitby. That puts us in the below-average tier for growth right now. It is not last place, but it is not leading the pack either. Here is how the neighbours stack up on price:

• Ashburn: $1,974,971 average HonestDoor Price - the priciest of the group
• Myrtle Station: $1,741,908 - a step above Myrtle on price
• Myrtle: $1,586,870 - solid mid-range for the area
• Columbus: $1,170,436 - the most affordable nearby option

Myrtle is not the cheapest option around, and it is not the most expensive. It sits in a comfortable middle ground - which actually makes it attractive to a wide range of buyers.

The So What - Should You Sell This Summer?

If you are thinking about listing this summer, here is the straight talk. The 5.27% price increase in your HonestDoor Price is a real positive. Buyers looking in this part of Whitby are still paying well over $1.5 million for houses in Myrtle. That is a strong floor.

But the short-term dip of 2.85% and the below-average growth rank of 7 out of 11 tell us that waiting for prices to climb further may not be the safe bet right now. If your plan is to sell, pricing sharp and moving while demand is still present is smarter than holding out for a rebound that is not guaranteed.

On the rental side, $5,738 per month with a 4.08% yield is a reasonable return if you are weighing a hold strategy. And with Airbnb potential at $285 per night and a rank of 6th in Whitby, short-term rental is a legitimate option worth running the numbers on.

Bottom line - Myrtle is a high-value neighbourhood that is pausing, not falling. Check your HonestDoor Price today, know your real number, and make your move with clear eyes.

This information is all based on our opinions based on the information available to us. Everyone's situation may be different and you should reach out to us for more personalized information.