Dagmar, Whitby - September 2026 Real Estate Report

Dagmar, Whitby Real Talk: Your Neighbour's Honest Take on What's Happening Right Now

The Vibe Right Now

If you've been watching the "For Sale" signs in Dagmar lately, here's what's actually happening. The market is taking a breather - and depending on whether you own a house or a condo, that breather feels very different.

Houses: Still Big Money, But Watch the Trend

The average HonestDoor Price for a house in Dagmar sits at $1,929,190 - up 9.23% from the previous period. That's the good news. But the predicted market value right now is $1,766,251, which is sliding below the 3-month moving average of $1,867,523. In plain language, the peak may have already passed for the short term.

• HonestDoor Price (houses): $1,929,190
• Recent price change: -7.27%
• Predicted value vs. 3-month average: $1,766,251 vs. $1,867,523
• Estimated monthly rent: $6,214
• Rental yield: 3.79%
• Airbnb rank in Whitby: 3rd out of comparable neighbourhoods
• Neighbourhood growth rank: 11 out of 11

That last number is the one to pay attention to. On the neighbourhood leaderboard for growth, Dagmar houses are sitting dead last - 11th out of 11 comparable Whitby neighbourhoods. That doesn't mean your house isn't worth serious money. It just means the momentum has stalled compared to the competition. Nearby Ashburn is slightly pricier at $1,974,971, while Myrtle Station ($1,741,908) and Myrtle ($1,586,870) are both cheaper. We're still in the upper tier - but we're not leading the pack right now.

One bright spot: if you're thinking about short-term rentals, Dagmar ranks 3rd in Whitby for Airbnb potential, with an average estimate of $328 per night. That's a real number worth knowing if you have a secondary suite or are considering your options.

Condos: The Numbers Are Harder to Ignore

We'll be straight with you here. The condo picture in Dagmar is tougher. The average HonestDoor Price is $476,500 - down 5.00% from the previous period. The predicted value of $501,600 is also well below the 3-month moving average of $552,500. And the recent price change of -16.65% is a significant drop.

• HonestDoor Price (condos): $476,500
• Recent price change: -16.65%
• Predicted value vs. 3-month average: $501,600 vs. $552,500
• Estimated monthly rent: $2,550
• Rental yield: 3.85%
• Airbnb rank in Whitby: 8th out of comparable neighbourhoods
• Neighbourhood growth rank: 9 out of 9

On the condo leaderboard, Dagmar ranks 9th out of 9. Every nearby neighbourhood - Ashburn, Myrtle Station, and Brooklin - is priced higher. If you own a condo here and you've been sitting on the fence about selling, this data is worth a serious look before the gap widens further.

The Secret Sauce: Why Your HonestDoor Price Matters More Than Your Tax Assessment

Here's the thing most Dagmar homeowners don't realize. Your city tax assessment is a snapshot from the past - sometimes 12 to 24 months old by the time it lands in your mailbox. It doesn't know what happened to prices last quarter. It doesn't know your street's recent sales. It's essentially a history lesson dressed up as a current number.

The HonestDoor Price is updated in real time using actual market data. Right now, with house values in Dagmar showing a -7.27% recent shift and condos down -16.65%, the gap between what the city thinks your home is worth and what a buyer would actually pay today could be significant - in either direction. Knowing your real-world number isn't just interesting. It's the difference between pricing your home right and leaving money on the table - or scaring buyers away entirely.

So What Does This Mean If You're Thinking About Selling This Summer?

Timing matters right now. For house owners, you're still holding a high-value asset - $1.9M average is nothing to dismiss. But with growth ranking last in the neighbourhood comparison and values trending below the 3-month average, waiting for the market to "come back" before listing is a gamble. Summer buyer activity is real, and a well-priced home at $1.7M-$1.9M will attract attention. A stale listing at last year's peak price won't.

For condo owners, the urgency is higher. A -16.65% recent price change and a last-place growth ranking means the window for a strong sale is narrowing. If you've been thinking about it, this summer is likely a better moment than next fall.

Either way, the first step is knowing your actual number - not the city's outdated guess. Check your HonestDoor Price, compare it to what's moving in Ashburn and Brooklin, and make a decision based on real data. That's how smart Dagmar homeowners play this market.

This information is all based on our opinions based on the information available to us. Everyone's situation may be different and you should reach out to us for more personalized information.