If you live in Rosenthal Estates, you already know this is not your average Stony Plain street. The average HonestDoor Price here sits at $1,272,356 - that is more than double what homes are fetching in nearby Willow Park ($546,426) or Westerra Stage 15 ($539,423). Even Genesis On The Lakes, which is no slouch at $692,960, is not in the same conversation. We are talking about a neighbourhood that plays in a completely different price tier than everything around it.
That said, we need to be straight with each other. The predicted market value for houses here is currently $1,240,033, and that number is sitting below the 3-month moving average of $1,273,407. Values have dipped 1.01% recently, and on the neighbourhood growth leaderboard across Stony Plain, Rosenthal Estates ranks 35 out of 38. That is bottom-tier growth territory right now. The market is taking a breather, and pretending otherwise does not help anyone.
Here is the thing about your city tax assessment: it is a snapshot from the past. It does not know what happened in the market last month, last quarter, or even last year in real time. The HonestDoor Price is a live, data-driven estimate that moves with the market - not on a government schedule.
Right now, that distinction matters a lot. Your assessment might still reflect the stronger numbers from earlier periods. Your HonestDoor Price is telling you the real-world story today - and that story includes a slight softening. Knowing the difference between those two numbers is not just interesting trivia. It is the difference between pricing your home right and sitting on the market too long wondering why nobody is biting.
Check your HonestDoor Price now, not when the next assessment rolls around. The market does not wait for paperwork.
If you are not selling, there is still a compelling reason to pay attention. Rosenthal Estates holds the number one Airbnb rank in all of Stony Plain. Estimated short-term rental income runs around $246 per night. Long-term rental estimates come in at $4,954 per month, with a rental yield of 4.30%. That is a moderate but real return on a home valued well over a million dollars. For homeowners thinking about renting out a suite or exploring short-term options, this neighbourhood is sitting at the top of the city for that kind of opportunity.
If you have been thinking about listing, here is the honest take. You are sitting on a high-value asset in a neighbourhood that still commands premium prices compared to everything around it. That is real leverage. But the growth rank of 35 out of 38 and the recent -1.01% value shift are signals worth taking seriously. The market is not collapsing - but it is not accelerating either.
Selling this summer means getting ahead of any further softening. Waiting for the market to bounce back assumes it will bounce back quickly - and right now the data does not guarantee that. If your life circumstances line up with a sale, the current HonestDoor Price of $1,272,356 still puts you in a strong position relative to every neighbour around you. That gap will not last forever if growth continues to lag.
Bottom line: pull up your HonestDoor Price today, compare it to what you paid, and have an honest conversation about timing. The numbers are there. Use them.
rosenthal estates | stony plain | june 2026This information is all based on our opinions based on the information available to us. Everyone's situation may be different and you should reach out to us for more personalized information.